Personal bankruptcy laws exist to allow honest but unfortunate individuals to remove the burden of crushing debts. This enables them to become productive members of society.
Sounds good, right? It sure does – but not without a cost:
First, the act of filing for bankruptcy divests a debtor of his assets. With certain exceptions, his assets will become the legal property of the bankruptcy trustee, who is required to liquidate these assets and distribute the proceeds to his creditors. The exceptions (i.e., what you can keep) in Ontario, Canada are:
- personal use vehicle up to $5,650
- RRSPs, however any contributions made within 12 months prior to filing bankruptcy are seized by the trustee
- tools of trade up to $11,300
- personal effects up to $5,650
- household furniture up to $11,300
- life insurance policies with a cash surrender value if the beneficiary is the child, grandchild, parent or grandparent of the debtor
Fortunately, most people only have assets that fall within the above categories, so losing any assets is a non-issue. However, there are two types of asset situations which are quite common and require further explanation.
If you own a home and you happen to own it “free and clear” (i.e., it’s mortgage-free), the trustee will have to realize on it. He’ll do this in one of two ways: (1) he’ll sell it; or (2) you’ll find some way to buy him out so you can keep the home. For example, you may have a family member that can help you pay the trustee the fair market value of the home so you don’t lose it.
If you own a home with a mortgage, the trustee will calculate if it has any equity by obtaining the fair market value of the home and the current mortgage balance. If there is no equity (i.e., mortgage plus selling costs > fair market value), the trustee will have no interest in the home. If there is equity (i.e., fair market value > mortgage plus selling costs), you’ll have to pay the trustee the difference in order to keep the home. Again, you can obtain the assistance of a friend or family member to pay the trustee this equity amount.
So now you’ve dealt with the trustee – now, what about the bank? So long as your mortgage payments are current, you won’t have any problems with your bank in keeping the home, even if you are bankrupt. They do not want your home – they want to keep making money off you by charging you interest on the mortgage loan. Therefore, so long as the mortgage payments are current, they are happy.
As stated above, you can keep a personal use vehicle if its fair market value is less than $5,650. What happens if it’s worth more than that? Well, it depends….
If the vehicle is owned free and clear, the trustee will be required to liquidate it. He’ll either: (1) sell it; or (2) you can buy him out by getting help from a friend or family member.
However, more often than not, a car will either be leased or financed.
A leased vehicle is property of the leasing company and does not belong to you. Since it wasn’t your property to begin with, the trustee has no interest in it. Furthermore, so long as your lease payments are current, the leasing company will not care if you’re bankrupt. They don’t want the car – they want to keep making money off you from the interest they charge on the lease payments. So no worries there.
On the other hand, a vehicle that is financed DOES belong to you, and the trustee may have an interest in the vehicle. Whether he does or not will depend on the fair market of the vehicle and the balance on the loan. If the fair market value > loan balance plus estimated selling costs (i.e., the vehicle has equity), then you’ll have to pay the trustee the difference in order to keep the car. If it does not, then the trustee won’t have any interest in this vehicle.
That’s it for assets. Now let’s talk about what you’ll be paying to the trustee.
What you are required to pay will depend on your monthly net income (that is, income after taxes are deducted from your pay).
There is a concept in bankruptcy law called “surplus income”. The philosophy behind this concept is this: if you’re taking advantage of personal bankruptcy laws to get rid of a lot of debt, you are required to pay a portion of your net monthly income to the bankruptcy trustee for the benefit of your creditors.
How much you’ll be paying is determined by a “monthly living allowance” guideline established by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy, called the Superintendent’s Standards. Here are the Standards for 2010:
Single person $1,884
Family of two $2,345
Family of three $2,883
Family of four $3,501
Family of five $3,971
Family of six $4,478
Family of seven $4,986
Hence, a single person should be able to live on monthly net income of $1,884 per month and pay for his food, shelter, and entertainment.
So if Joe Smith, who earned a monthly net income of $3,000 had to file for bankruptcy, he’d be required to pay $558 for every month he’s bankrupt. This is calculated as follows:
(Net income – Superintendent’s Standard) x 50% = Required Payment
($3,000 – $1,884) x 50% = $558
As another example, let’s say Joe Smith and Nancy Smith (who’s net income per month is $2,000) were a married couple, were both in debt, and had to file bankruptcy together. They’d be required to pay $1,328 per month:
($5,000 – $2,345) x 50% = $1,328
So how long does this have to be paid? If the above calculation formula results in a Required Payment amount of at least $100, you will be required to make payments for 21 months. You’ll be discharged from bankruptcy only when you’ve completed your 21 required payments. If the Required Payment amount is less than $100, you’ll only be in bankruptcy for 9 months.
If you are filing bankruptcy a second time and the Required Payment amount is at least $100, you’ll be required to make payments for 36 months. If the Required Payment amount is less than $100, you’ll be in bankruptcy for 24 months.
OTHER THINGS TO KNOW
- The trustee is required to prepare and file your personal income tax return for the year of bankruptcy. Therefore, if you filed bankruptcy in 2010, he’ll be required to file your 2010 tax return. In the event there is a refund, you will lose the refund, as it will be sent to the trustee’s office by the Canada Revenue Agency. The trustee distributes the refund proceeds to your creditors.
- You are required to keep a monthly income/expense statements and attend two financial counselling sessions during the bankruptcy.
- Filing bankruptcy does not actually get rid of your debts; it only protects you from legal proceedings by your creditors (i.e., wage garnishments, liens, etc.). Your debts are extinguished only when you obtain your discharge from bankruptcy, and you will only be discharged if you’ve (1) cooperated with the trustee in realizing your assets; (2) made the required surplus income payments; (3) prepared monthly income/expense statements and attended financial counselling.
- A record of your bankruptcy stays on your credit file during the time you are bankrupt and 6 years after the date of your discharge from bankruptcy. However, notwithstanding your credit record, you can start rebuilding your credit immediately after your discharge. The most efficient way to do this would be to obtain a secured credit card.
- The trustee’s fees are paid from the trust funds which resulted from realizing your assets, collecting your surplus income payments and processing your income tax refund. His fees are calculated according to a tariff in the bankruptcy act.
So you’ve just realized the mistake you made purchasing your Toronto property in 2017 during the market’s peak (which appears to have been in the Fall of 2017 according to this chart at www.toronto.listing.ca).
Read More »
What are the hallmarks of a middle class lifestyle? And how much does a household residing in Toronto have to earn to be considered middle class?
First, let’s define “Toronto”. “Toronto” means the City of Toronto. I’m not including the satellite cities in the Greater Toronto Area...Read More »
A bankrupt debtor who was ordered by the Court to pay $35,000 to the Canada Revenue Agency, which was the major creditor in her bankruptcy because of unpaid income taxes.
At issue in this court case was whether the bankrupt in question was “an honest but unfortunate debtor”.
Successful entrepreneurship – to many people, achieving this is a mystery. We’ve heard stories of penniless immigrants who came to Canada with nothing but a dream, but within a single generation accumulate a lot of wealth. How do they do it?
This is a mystery to the...Read More »
So you’ve filed your personal bankruptcy or consumer proposal with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee but for whatever reason, you haven’t been happy with the service you’ve received. Is it possible to replace your Trustee?
This will depend on the type of engagement you’re currently undergoing.
Your proposal hasn’t yet been approved
If...Read More »
Home Capital Group has been having a lot of problems over the past few months. Here is a perspective from Rachelle Berube, who is the Toronto-based writer and property manager of the blog LandlordRescue.ca. We have reposted her blog post, the original post can be...Read More »
The Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act states that student loans under a federal or provincial student loan program are not discharged from bankruptcy if you have filed for bankruptcy within 7 years of last attending school.
So practically speaking, what this means is that you’ll have to wait for 7 years from...Read More »
Millennials, it appears that you’re being economically squeezed out of the transition to adulthood. An excerpt from the news article by CBC News’ Kate McGillivray, April 5, 2017:
A new report out from Vancouver-based campaign Generation Squeeze says Ontario has the second-worst economy for young people in the country, eclipsed only...Read More »
The Toronto real estate market gets crazier and crazier – from the Canadian Press, April 5, 2017:
The Toronto area saw real estate prices soar again last month, with the average jumping 33.2 per cent from the same time last year.
The Toronto Real Estate Board says the average price in the...Read More »
This is a repost of an article I posted in January 2012. Donald Trump was recently elected U.S. President largely by working class Americans in the rustbelt states of Pennsylvania, Michigan, Ohio and Wisconsin (which were previously carried by Barack Obama in the 2012 elections).
The...Read More »
TRUMP PRESIDENCY – INTRODUCTION
As we head into the year 2017, we are faced with the possible consequences of a Trump Presidency; consequences that will reverberate throughout the world. Trump will certainly have an impact of the geopolitical landscape, but the economic impact of his administration will...Read More »
Stephanie has discussed filing for bankruptcy with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee. The trustee explains how Stephanie’s income requires her to make payments during her bankruptcy.
Meet Stephanie, the mother of a young son, James, who is just about to enter primary school.
Recently, Stephanie has overextended...Read More »
Vincent has decided to file for bankruptcy. His Licensed Insolvency Trustee outlines what debts will be discharged in a bankruptcy and how long the process takes.
Meet Vincent, a father of two young children. A recent separation has left him unable to meet his financial obligations.
A Licensed Insolvency Trustee explains to Mary and Paul that a consumer proposal might be the way to resolve their financial situation. The trustee tells them how a consumer proposal is different from bankruptcy and what they need to do.
Mary took a job...Read More »
After talking with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee, David and Julie decide that bankruptcy is the most appropriate option to handle their debts. The trustee explains the way their creditors will be paid and what they will need to do during the bankruptcy process.
It’s been a tough time for...Read More »
Richard is unable to pay his bills and unsure what to do. He talks to a Licensed Insolvency Trustee to explore the different ways he can deal with his debt.
This is Richard.
Unable to pay his bills, he is unsure what to do.
On...Read More »
On January 1, 2015, the Collection Agencies Act (Ontario) was renamed the Collection and Debt Settlement Services Act (the “CDSSA”), and provisions were added that deal specifically with debt settlement services. Starting July 1, 2015, these new provisions and the regulation will, among other things, provide greater protection...Read More »
The actions of the Bank of Canada in slashing its key interest rate since the 2008 financial crisis has created a large number of individual debtors who are desperately seeking debt relief but are unable to do so because of real estate asset inflation. I have consulted with...Read More »
When you first move to Toronto, you’ll likely be renting your living space. But after renting for a few years, you’re going to ask yourself this question: is it better to rent or buy a home in Toronto?
Maybe you want to purchase your own place for...Read More »
I was part of a generational cohort born in the 1970s that graduated university and entered the workforce in the mid-1990s while Canada was still in a recession. We were the so called “slacker” generation because we apparently had no ambition and no hope.
In my case,...Read More »
A news article published in the New York Times describes an alleged practice in the United States in which certain banks are systematically ignoring discharge orders granted to individuals who had filed personal bankruptcy. These discharged bankrupts continue to be hounded by their...Read More »
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada website has a comprehensive guide to credit reports called Understanding your Credit Report and Credit Score, here.
Each item in the table of contents links to a page containing valuable information about credit reports. Pretty much everything you need...Read More »
When a consumer proposal is filed by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (“OSB”), the trustee will send a copy of the proposal to your creditors for their review and evaluation.
Your creditors have 45 days from the date your proposal...Read More »
“Who is the best Licensed Insolvency Trustee in Toronto?”
If you came across this blog post after entering this search query into Google, you’re not alone. This is one of the most obvious questions to ask when seeking the services of a Toronto Licensed Insolvency Trustee.
This is a question that is often asked. The answer is pretty simple:
Yesterday, I met with a lady by the name of Dawn (not her real name). Dawn is a single mother of two daughters – 14 years and 18 years old respectively. She earns a salary of $40,000 per year and has about $60,000 in credit card debt.
To answer your question: who is eligible to file a consumer proposal or personal bankruptcy? Let’s look at a case study – I just met with a very nice gentleman today in our Brampton location – let’s call him Jake (not his real name).
Jake had $12,000...Read More »
Kerri (not her real name) was a third-year student enrolled at York University working towards the completion of her psychology degree. She had accumulated credit card debt since her first year of university after applying for a credit card on campus.
She had $12,000 in credit card...Read More »
Don (not his real name) was in a real pickle. He was a gentleman in his late 50s supporting a family of three, consisting of his stay at home wife and young niece. He was the sole income earner in the household, which was stressful enough, but he...Read More »
One bright and sunny afternoon, I was taking a leisurely stroll in my neighbourhood of King & Spadina. I was struck by the number of condominium projects either in construction or in development within just a 1 km radius of the King...Read More »
When you leave a job, you’ll typically have retirement savings locked in through pension legislation at your place of work. You’ll usually have a choice between leaving the monies in your pension plan or transferring it to a locked-in retirement account (LIRA), which is essentially an...Read More »
Defining the Problem
When I reflect on the subject of rising tuition costs and student loan debt in Canada, I’m struck by its parallels with the events that led to the U.S. housing crisis:
- Easy credit backstopped by the federal government allowed individuals who had no...Read More »
“Be thankful for what you have; you’ll end up having more. If you concentrate on what you don’t have, you will never, ever have enough.” – Oprah Winfrey
How difficult is it to live on $196,000 in Toronto?
Well, according to an article published by Toronto...Read More »
I do not use the term “extraordinary” very often to describe books, but this one qualifies as a TRULY extraordinary book.
It is extraordinary because it was first published in December 1996 and has accurately predicted the following events which have since transpired:
- The September 11...Read More »
This is by far the best documentary I’ve seen which explains the reasons for the ongoing financial crisis that started in October 2008.
BBC business editor Robert Peston examines how the world got to this point and how the colossal imbalances in the global economy have left...Read More »
Robert Kiyosaki is the best-selling author of the “Rich Dad Poor Dad” series of financial education books, which have collectively sold over 26 million copies worldwide. This makes him one of the best-selling business writers of all time.
A large part of the appeal of Kiyosaki’s books...Read More »
Kyle Bass is a Texas hedge fund manager who predicted the U.S. subprime housing crisis and made millions from being right in his predictions. He is now betting on the collapse of entire countries in Europe. Many of his predictions are frightening, but as you’ll see in this...Read More »
“Where should I invest my money?“
I’m frequently asked this question, and almost invariably, the speaker asks it in a tone of fear and concern.
And there is much to be frightened and concerned about. As of this writing, the European Union is on...Read More »
I had the pleasure of being a guest panelist on the Dash Show. The Dash Show is the media outlet of the Online Party of Canada, which is is a political party founded by Michael Nicula “enabling direct democracy in the internet era“.
The topic of discussion was a...Read More »
I am often asked what is the best debt counselling service available to someone who wishes to get out of debt without going bankrupt.
The answer to this question depends on the severity of the debtor’s situation:
- If one is able to repay all debts in...Read More »
You may have noticed a recent proliferation of telemarketing calls, TV ads and radio ads from “non-profit” debt management/debt counselling companies in the Greater Toronto Area.
Almost all of these companies are U.S. based, and they have been aggressively moving into the GTA because their highly questionable...Read More »
Once a debtor has been discharged from bankruptcy, she can obtain a secured credit card to start rebuilding her credit.
Contrary to popular belief, a debtor who has been discharged from bankruptcy doesn’t have to wait 7 years (the length a bankruptcy stays on a credit file) to re-establish her credit...Read More »
Your debts can be settled for as little 35% of what you owe – simply, quickly and legally.
The only distinction between provinces on how filing bankruptcy affects you is with respect to what assets you can keep. In Ontario, the main statutes that govern what assets are exempt from seizure by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee are the Pension Benefits Act, Insurance Act and Executions Act....Read More »
The bankruptcy process in Canada is governed by a federal statue called the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (“BIA”). Under the BIA, the major steps in the bankruptcy process are:
- Meet with a trustee to evaluate your financial situation
- File an assignment in bankruptcy with the Office of the...Read More »
There are 2 types of RRSPs: (1) RRSPs set up with a life insurance company; and (2) RRSPs set up anywhere else, like with a bank or mutual fund company.
An RRSP set up with a life insurance company is also called a segregated fund. This type...Read More »
“Can I keep my car when filing for personal bankruptcy?”.
This is a common question and the answer depends on the circumstances…
If a car is owned outright by a debtor (i.e., it is not leased or subject to a loan), she can keep the vehicle...Read More »
One of the questions we’re most often asked is: “can I keep my home if I file for personal bankruptcy?”
The answer to this question depends on your situation.There are 2 types of situations:
- The value of the debtor’s home is less than the mortgage balance;...Read More »
Generally speaking, someone who files bankruptcy for the first or second time will get what is called an automatic discharge from bankruptcy.
Years ago (pre-1992), someone that filed bankruptcy had to attend bankruptcy court to obtain her discharge from bankruptcy. She had to demonstrate to the court...Read More »
You probably came across this blog post because you were looking for a solution for your debt problems and Googled “Toronto Bankruptcy Lawyer”.
When someone is contemplating filing for personal bankruptcy, the first thing that comes to mind is to find a bankruptcy lawyer.
What’s often...Read More »
So what is the difference between these two methods of dealing with debt? Simply put:
- A debt consolidation requires you to repay all of your debts, albeit on favourable terms.
- A debt settlement allows you to repay some of your debt on favourable terms. The balance of what you owe is legally...Read More »
The rise of the United States as the major world economic power in the last half of the 20th century coincided with the rise of the American middle class. That rise started with the 1944 GI Bill, which provided returning American veterans with money for college, businesses and...Read More »
The following post is a primer on the types of debt and how they are dealt with in the context of a bankruptcy.
There are two types of debt: (1) unsecured; and (2) secured.
Unsecured debt is not secured by an asset. The bank provides...Read More »
According to professional economists and the media, much of the developed world (i.e., North America, Europe and Japan) is currently in a recession.
A “recession” is generally defined as a slowdown in economic activity for a period of time. This definition implies that economic activity...Read More »
Sarah Ferguson, the Duchess of York, is contemplating filing for personal bankruptcy. A news story about her circumstances can be found here.
This goes to show that even outwardly successful people can find themselves in unexpected dire financial straits. So it’s not just ordinary...Read More »
The Canada Revenue Agency (“CRA”) has significant powers under the Income Tax Act (“ITA”) to collect personal income tax debt. This post examines the collection procedures most commonly used.
Charge over real property
Under Section 223 of the ITA, the CRA can register a lien over...Read More »
There is a lot of misconception of what creditors can and cannot do to collect their debts. To dispel some myths, this post will walk you through the steps a creditor will typically take in collecting its debt.
Please note that the content of this post applies...Read More »
I read a very interesting report from the New York Times that claims the majority of “debt settlement companies” (i.e., unlicensed and unregulated businesses offering debt relief) in the United States are fraudulent or deceptive, with very few businesses working towards the best interest of their clients. A...Read More »
Despite beliefs to the contrary, personal income tax debt is treated no differently than most other types of debt under Canadian bankruptcy law. However, this statement comes with a caveat, which we’ll examine later later in this post.
Here is a typical scenario that I’ve come across...Read More »
Gambling has become a major problem in our society. I have come across many individuals who became heavily indebted because of compulsive gambling.
Filing for personal bankruptcy is an option that naturally comes to mind if someone finds herself with a lot of gambling debt. However, there are a few things...Read More »
During my career, I’ve had the opportunity to come across some great people in my profession from across the country. So if you’ve come across our website and are living outside of the Greater Toronto Area, here are some trustee’s you may want to check out, depending on...Read More »
When choosing to work with a trustee in bankruptcy, there are 2 things you should be aware of: (1) his legal role with respect to your bankruptcy proceedings; and (2) his professional standing with respect to his competence and ethical conduct. These two aspects are discussed below.
The world finds itself in the midst of the Great Recession that came to full fruition in September 2008 with the collapse of Lehman Brothers. Many have asked this simple question – “how can this have happened?”
So why are we in this mess? Before...Read More »
The business of debt counselling (a.k.a. credit counselling) and debt consolidation is an extremely competitive one, particularly in Toronto. Unfortunately, there are certain financial professionals who employ questionable methods in marketing their services to get an edge over their competition.
There has been a trend of “credit counsellors”, “debt...Read More »
A reputable credit counselling agency can play a useful role in helping you facilitate a plan to deal with your debts. The program offered by such agencies is called a debt management plan.
A debt management plan is an arrangement facilitated by a credit counselling agency whereby...Read More »
Throughout my career as a bankruptcy trustee, I have seen the following scenario play out time and time again:
- Girl meets boy and falls in love. He’s not perfect – he could be irresponsible at times – but he makes her laugh and makes her feel good....Read More »